| Show # | 2012# | Date | Theme |
| 459 | 1 | 1/2 | First #1 Billboard Charted Hit Of The Year |
| 460 | 2 | 1/9 | Artists of the British Invasion |
| 461 | 3 | 1/16 | RIGHT |
| 462 | 4 | 1/23 | RAIN |
| 463 | 5 | 1/30 | OUT OF |
| 464 | 6 | 2/6 | Rhyming Two Word Title |
| 465 | 7 | 2/13 | LOVE - title starts with |
| 466 | 8 | 2/20 | George Artists |
| 467 | 9 | 2/27 | Movie Actors |
| 468 | 10 | 3/5 | NIGHT title ends with |
| 469 | 11 | 3/12 | NIGHT title ends with |
| 470 | 12 | 3/19 | Heartache - Heartbreak |
| 471 | 13 | 3/26 | Game |
| 472 | 14 | 4/2 | Stones - Rocks |
| 473 | 15 | 4/9 | WAY - title ends with |
| 474 | 16 | 4/30 | COMES |
| 475 | 17 | 5/7 | Insects |
| 476 | 18 | 5/14 | Birds |
| 477 | 19 | 5/21 | Birds |
| 478 | 20 | 5/28 | Remember |
| 479 | 21 | 6/4 | Answer Songs |
| 480 | 22 | 6/11 | Answer Songs |
| 481 | 23 | 6/18 | Diamonds |
| 482 | 24 | 7/2 | AMERICA |
| 483 | 25 | 7/9 | STAR |
| 484 | 26 | 7/16 | Initials in artists name |
| 485 | 27 | 7/23 | Alcohol |
| 486 | 28 | 7/30 | San Francisco Area Artists |
| 487 | 29 | 8/6 | WALKIN |
| 488 | 30 | 8/13 | Left Handed Artists |
| 489 | 31 | 8/27 | Dog |
| 490 | 32 | 9/3 | WATER |
| 491 | 33 | 9/10 | WITHOUT |
| 492 | 34 | 9/17 | Artists Named Bill |
| 493 | 35 | 9/24 | BACK |
| 494 | 36 | 10/1 | TEAR |
| 495 | 37 | 10/8 | Trees |
| 496 | 38 | 10/15 | Shoes |
| 497 | 39 | 10/22 | Cold Weather Getaways |
| 498 | 40 | 10/29 | UNDER |
| 499 | 41 | 11/5 | WAIT |
| 500 | 42 | 11/12 | Groovy |
| 501 | 43 | 11/19 | Top 10 Songs Under 2 Minutes Long |
| 502 | 44 | 11/26 | CHRISTMAS |