| Play order | Song | Recording Artist |
| 1 | The Dating Game Theme | |
| 2 | It's Late | Ricky Nelson |
| 3 | Come Dancing | Kinks |
| 4 | My Last Date (With You) | Joni James |
| 5 | Claudette | Everly Brothers |
| 6 | Rip It Up |
Little Richard |
| 7 | Summertime Blues | Eddie Cochran |
| 8 | (Just Like) Romeo & Juliet | Reflections |
| 9 | Drive-In | Beach Boys |
| 10 | An Empty Cup (And A Broken Date) | Buddy Holly |
| 11 | Hey Now | Lesley Gore |
| 12 | Western Movies | Olympics |
| 13 | Saturday Night | Bay City Rollers |
| 14 | First Date, First Kiss, First Love | Sonny James |
| 15 | Respectable |
Outsiders |
| 16 |
You're More Than A Number In My Redbook |
Drifters |
| 17 | Tell Him No | Travis & Bob |
| 18 | Over And Over | Dave Clark Five |
| 19 | Poor Jenny | Everly Brothers |
| 20 | Harper Valley PTA | Jeannie C. Riley |
| 21 | (Girls, Girls, Girls) Made To Love | Eddie Hodges |
| 22 | That's It I Quit - I'm Movin' On | Sam Cooke |
| 23 | Johnny Angel | Shelley Fabares |
| 24 | Last Kiss | J. Frank Wilson |
| 25 | Tra La La La Suzy | Dean & Jean |
| 26 | Smoke, Smoke, Smoke That Cigarette | Jimmy Dean |
| 27 | Did You Boogie | Flash Cadillac & The Continental Kids |
| 28 | Kiss And Say Goodbye | Manhattans |
| 29 | I Want To Walk You Home | Fats Domino |
| 30 | Beachwood 4-5789 | Marvelettes |
| 31 | This Little Girl Of Mine | Everly Brothers |
| 32 | Somethin' Else | Eddie Cochran |
| 33 | Your Mama Don't Dance | Loggins & Messina |
| 34 | Another Saturday Night | Sam Cooke |
| 35 | Pretty Ballerina | Left Banke |
| 36 | Charming Billy | Johnny Preston |
| 37 | Leaning On The Lamp Post | Herman's Hermits |
| 38 | Darktown Strutter's Ball | Fats Domino |
| 39 | That's Old Fashioned (That's The Way Love Should Be) | Everly Brothers |
| 40 | Wake Up Little Susie | Everly Brothers |
| 41 | Date Bait | Diane Maxwell |
| 42 | Last Date | Floyd Cramer |
| 43 | ||
| 44 | ||
| 45 | ||
| 46 | ||
| 47 |