| Play order | Song | Recording Artist Age |
| 1 | Lonely Boy | Paul Anka |
| 2 | My Special Angel | Bobby Helms |
| 3 | Your Precious Love | Marvin Gaye & Tammi Terrell |
| 4 | Heaven Must Have Sent You | Bonnie Pointer |
| 5 | You Drive Me Crazy | Shakin' Stevens |
| 6 | The Angels Listened In |
Crests |
| 7 | Heaven Must Have Sent You (Here In The Night) | Frankie Valli & The Four Seasons |
| 8 | You're The One | Buddy Holly |
| 9 | Heaven Must Have Made You Just For Me | Johnny Mathis |
| 10 | With Your Love | Jefferson Starship |
| 11 | Venus In Blue Jeans | Jimmy Clanton |
| 12 | Every Breath I Take | Gene Pitney |
| 13 | Could It Be I'm Falling In Love | Spinners |
| 14 | Pretty Little Angel Eyes | Curtis Lee |
| 15 | We've Got Love |
Peaches & Herb |
| 16 | Sweet And Lovely | Sir Henry & His Butlers |
| 17 | Heaven Must Be Missing An Angel | Tavares |
| 18 | You Make Me Feel Brand New | Stylistics |
| 19 | My True Love | Jack Scott |
| 20 | Heaven Sent You I Know | Marvin Gaye & Kim Weston |
| 21 | Memories Are Made Of This | Dean Martin |
| 22 | Ain't No Woman (Like The One I Got) | Four Tops |
| 23 | Heaven Must Have Sent You | Elgins |
| 24 | The Angels Gave You To Me | Johnny Preston |
| 25 | Guess Things Happen That Way | Johnny Cash |
| 26 | (I've Got) Bonnie | Bobby Rydell |
| 27 | Hundred Pounds Of Clay | Gene McDaniels |
| 28 | Honeycomb | Jimmie Rodgers |
| 29 | The Angels Must Have Made You | Two Of Clubs |
| 30 | Swearin' To God | Frankie Valli |
| 31 | Blue Moon | Marcels |
| 32 | My Special Angel | Vogues |
| 33 | It's You | Dionne Warwick with Stevie Wonder |
| 34 | My Destiny | Lionel Richie |
| 35 | ||
| 36 | ||
| 37 | ||
| 38 | ||
| 39 | ||
| 40 | ||
| 41 | ||
| 42 | ||
| 43 | ||
| 44 | ||
| 45 | ||
| 46 | ||
| 47 |