| Play order | Song | Artist |
| 1 | He's The Man With All The Toys | Beach Boys |
| 2 | Toy Sack | Bob Rivers |
| 3 | Cuddly Toy | Monkees |
| 4 | Toy Soldier | Four Seasons |
| 5 | Jerry Mathers | |
| 6 | Toymaker | Association |
| 7 | Rubber Ball | Bobby Vee |
| 8 | Rubber Ducky | Jim Henson as Ernie |
| 9 | Hula Hoop Song | Teresa Brewer |
| 10 | Yo-Yo | Osmonds |
| 11 | River Deep Mountain High | Ike & Tina Turner |
| 12 | I'm Your Puppet | James & Bobby Purify |
| 13 | (Let Me Be Your) Teddy Bear | Elvis Presley |
| 14 | Hearts In Her Eyes | Searchers |
| 15 | Cowboys To Girls | Intruders |
| 16 | Yellow Balloon | Yellow Balloon |
| 17 | Cry Like A Baby | Box Tops |
| 18 | Brand New Key | Melanie |
| 19 | Old Toy Trains | Roger Miller |
| 20 | All You Need Is Elves | Bob Rivers |
| 21 | Santa Claus Go Straight To The Ghetto | James Brown |
| 22 | I Want A Hippopotamus For Christmas | Gayla Peevey |
| 23 | It's Beginning To Look Alot Like Christmas | Johnny Mathis |
| 24 | The Chipmunk Song | David Seville |
| 25 | Old Days | Chicago |
| 26 | Toys In The Attic | Aerosmith |
| 27 | Broomstick Cowboy | Bobby Goldsboro |
| 28 | Where The Toys Are | Neil Sedaka |
| 29 | Red Rubber Ball | Cyrkle |
| 30 | Puppet On A String | Elvis Presley |
| 31 | The Days Of Sand And Shovels | Bobby Vinton |
| 32 | Goin' Back | Byrds |
| 33 | Oh No, Not My Baby | Maxine Brown |
| 34 | All Of Your Toys | Monkees |
| 35 | Desdemona | Searchers |
| 36 | Bedtime For Toys | Stevie Wonder |
| 37 | ||
| 38 | ||
| 39 | ||
| 40 | ||
| 41 | ||
| 42 | ||
| 43 | ||
| 44 | ||
| 45 | ||
| 46 | ||
| 47 |