| Play order | Song | Artist |
| 1 | Apple Peaches Pumkin Pie | Jay & The Techniques |
| 2 | Cherry Pie | Skip & Flip |
| 3 | Country Pie | Bob Dylan |
| 4 | Porcupine Pie | Neil Diamond |
| 5 | Billy "Crash" Craddock | |
| 6 | Honey Pie | Beatles |
| 7 | American Pie | Don McLean |
| 8 | Pied Piper | Chrispian St. Peters |
| 9 | Rhubarb Pie | John Fogerty |
| 10 | Nothing Can Change This Love | Sam Cooke |
| 11 | I Can't Help Myself (Sugar Pie, Honey Bunch) | Four Tops |
| 12 | Rocking Around The Christmas Tree | Brenda Lee |
| 13 | Look Out (Here Comes Tomorrow) | Monkees |
| 14 | Georgy Porgy | Toto |
| 15 | Judy In Disguise (With Glasses) | John Fred & His Playboy Band |
| 16 | Beautiful Deliah | Chuck Berry |
| 17 | That's Amore | Dean Martin |
| 18 | Bitch | Rolling Stones |
| 19 | Uncle Albert - Admiral Halsey | Paul McCartney |
| 20 | Ro Ro Rosey | Van Morrison |
| 21 | The Jeffersons Theme (Movin' On Up) | |
| 22 | Lollipop | Chordettes |
| 23 | Jambalaya | John Fogerty |
| 24 | Daydream | Lovin' Spoonful |
| 25 | Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds | Beatles |
| 26 | Money | Pink Floyd |
| 27 | Blueberry Pie | Bette Middler |
| 28 | Sweet Potato Pie | James Taylor |
| 29 | Eat It | Weird Al Yankovic |
| 30 | As Long As There's An Apple Tree | Dionne Warwick |
| 31 | Bootleg | Creedence Clearwater Revival |
| 32 | Wild Honey Pie | Beatles |
| 33 | Amercian As Apple Pie | Eric Carmen |
| 34 | Hungarian Goulash No. 5 | Allan Sherman |
| 35 | The Village Green Preservation Society | Kinks |
| 36 | Flaming Pie | Paul McCartney |
| 37 | ||
| 38 | ||
| 39 | ||
| 40 | ||
| 41 | ||
| 42 | ||
| 43 | ||
| 44 | ||
| 45 | ||
| 46 | ||
| 47 |