| Show # | 2016# | Date | Theme |
| 651 | 1 | 1/4 | FIRST * |
| 652 | 2 | 1/11 | Lucky * |
| 653 | 3 | 1/18 | Yellow * |
| 654 | 4 | 1/25 | Judge * |
| 655 | 5 | 2/8 | NOW * |
| 656 | 6 | 2/15 | NOW * |
| 657 | 7 | 2/22 | Bill * |
| 658 | 8 | 2/29 | L.A. * |
| 659 | 9 | 3/7 | Book * |
| 660 | 10 | 3/14 | Pie * |
| 661 | 11 | 3/21 | Cloud * |
| 662 | 12 | 3/28 | Chains * |
| 663 | 13 | 4/4 | Newspapers * |
| 664 | 14 | 4/11 | Animal Sounds * |
| 665 | 15 | 4/18 | Whistling * |
| 666 | 16 | 4/25 | REALLY * |
| 667 | 17 | 5/2 | Mama * |
| 668 | 18 | 5/9 | YESTERDAY * |
| 669 | 19 | 5/16 | YOUNG * |
| 670 | 20 | 5/23 | Photograph * |
| 671 | 21 | 5/30 | REMEMBER * |
| 672 | 22 | 6/6 | FACE * |
| 673 | 23 | 6/13 | Follow * |
| 674 | 24 | 6/20 | STAY * |
| 675 | 25 | 6/27 | Seventeen * |
| 676 | 26 | 7/4 | Billboard Charted Songs With Titles of 10 Or More Words * |
| 677 | 27 | 7/11 | Fine * |
| 678 | 28 | 7/18 | Knife * |
| 679 | 29 | 7/25 | Park * |
| 680 | 30 | 8/1 | Step * |
| 681 | 31 | 8/8 | Getting Married * |
| 682 | 32 | 8/15 | TOO * |
| 683 | 33 | 8/22 | TOO * |
| 684 | 34 | 8/29 | Hide * |
| 685 | 35 | 9/5 | SCHOOL * |
| 686 | 36 | 9/19 | Roses * |
| 687 | 37 | 9/26 | James Dean * |
| 688 | 38 | 10/3 | LIKE * |
| 689 | 39 | 10/10 | LIKE * |
| 690 | 40 | 10/17 | THE RAIN * |
| 691 | 41 | 10/24 | title starts with COME * |
| 692 | 42 | 10/31 | Candy * |
| 693 | 43 | 11/7 | Phone Numbers * |
| 694 | 44 | 11/14 | Songs That Peaked At #2 And Remained For 3 Weeks * |
| 695 | 45 | 11/21 | Songs That Peaked At #2 And Remained For 3 Weeks * |
| 696 | 46 | 11/28 | Christmas * |
| 697 | 47 | 12/5 | Christmas * |
| 698 | 48 | 12/12 | Christmas * |
| 699 | 49 | 12/19 | Christmas * |
| 700 | 50 | 12/26 | Seven * |
| 701 | 51 |